A few years back several neighborhood specific books came out and I got a little excited. There are so many things I don't know about that any new information is compelling. Unfortunately, when the Stapleton book came out (my hometown) I was pretty underwhelmed. There are good pictures and information, don't get me wrong, but it just didn't feel well put together.
Well, that day's come. I'm in the middle of working on a post concerning Van Duzer Street, from Beach to Victory and the Elk's Club came back up. So I drove on over with my camera and started getting some pictures.
I think the pictures make it pretty clear the building of yesterday is the building of today. Sure it's been stripped of any attractive detailing and windows have been blocked and the mansard roof has been obliterated. But it's the same building. If you drive down the street you can still see the porch that's in the left of the postcard on the house next door.
It was hard to get a clear picture of the lowest portions of the building but if you enlarge it you can see the same same basement windows with curved tops. There's the outcropping on the left towards the rear and the whole two stage outcropping at the front. Pretty terrible devastation was wrought on this building but it must have been a beast to maintain.
So here are the maps from 1874, 1885 and 1917. Same building footprint (save the added bowling alley in by 1917), same location. Not only is it listed as the Elk's Club on the 1917 map but on the two earlier maps it's designated the Methfessel Institute. That means it's probably the first incarnation of Staten Island Academy prior to its move to Academy Place (originally Carroll Place). I did this mostly sitting at a desk looking at easily available maps and pictures. That's actually a very cool discovery. The photos were really only for my own satisfaction as the maps say it all.
I'm not expert on the history and architecture of the North Shore, only a motivated amateur. I hope I never present myself here as anything more. Still, I hope never to steer you wrong or fail to follow down any leads I can find. Of course I will and I hope to hear from you and be corrected as swiftly as possible. The fluidity of a blog and the ease of correction is definitely one of its greatest assets and I hope to utilize that to the best of my ability.
PS: While working on the Van Duzer post I found myself looking at the Amazon listing for the Stapleton book to make sure I was remembering the Elk's Club picture caption correctly when I came across another serious error. Which of course makes me wonder how many more there might be.
This one concerns a "double house" on the north side of Beach Street between Jackson and Van Duzer Streets. According to the authors the building, looking quite picturesque in 1927, drifted off into derelict status before being demolished in the 21st century. Here's a shot similar to one in the book but from 1931.
View Larger Map
I know this sounds like I'm just griping. At a certain level I surely am, but you know what, if you're going to put out a book take some time to go see the places you're writing about. Look at the maps. Get it right or leave it out.
PPS - It still is. I just drove past it.